Pop Culture / feature
Before GTA VI, the Indigenous Stories That Shaped Red Dead Redemption 2
Charles Smith, Rains Fall, Eagle Flies and Paytah put land, belonging and survival at the centre of Rockstar’s Western.

Contains major story spoilers for Red Dead Redemption 2.
Before Rockstar Games returns to Vice City, there are two men worth remembering: Charles Smith, helping others build a home while searching for one of his own, and Rains Fall, trying to keep his family and people alive.
In Red Dead Redemption 2, their choices help shape Arthur Morgan’s reckoning with the Van der Linde gang and the life John Marston tries to build afterwards. Set in 1899, the 2018 Western makes land, displacement, kinship and survival part of its central drama.
With Grand Theft Auto VI beginning its Nov. 19 release across time zones, it is a moment to revisit that work: the Indigenous characters, the performers behind them and the decisions that brought them into one of Rockstar’s biggest worlds.
Charles Smith: A Life Beyond the Gang
Charles is part of the story from its opening stretch in the snow. Born to a Black father and an Indigenous mother, he has lived through the Army’s displacement of his mother’s people and her capture by soldiers. His search for belonging brings him to Dutch van der Linde’s gang.
Charles hunts and tracks, fights beside Arthur and helps find shelter for the gang. He repeatedly directs those skills towards helping others, including reuniting a stranded family. On a bison hunt, he discovers animals killed and abandoned to rot; his anger leads him to kill one of the men responsible.
“All this death and for what?” he asks as the gang’s violence mounts.
Charles’ commitment to the Wapiti people becomes a major part of the later story. He and Arthur break Eagle Flies out of Fort Wallace, and Charles stays to help the Wapiti leave for Canada. In the epilogue, depending on the player’s earlier choices, Charles tells John he returned to bury Arthur.
His story continues in the 1907 epilogue. Reunited with John, Charles helps build the house at Beecher’s Hope and joins the search for Micah Bell. He speaks of going north to Canada and starting a family; the game leaves that future open.
Noshir Dalal performs Charles. In a 2018 Hollywood Reporter interview, quoted by GamesRadar+, Dalal described him as “half of one world and half of another and belongs in neither.” Dalal, who described his own background as Japanese and Parsi, said that experience of not quite belonging helped him connect with the character.
Through Charles, the game gives its Black and Indigenous character a life extending from the gang’s daily work to the possibility of a future beyond it.
Rains Fall: A Father, Diplomat and Survivor
The late Graham Greene, the Oneida actor from Six Nations of the Grand River, performs Rains Fall, chief of the fictional Wapiti people and father of Eagle Flies.
He arrives with a history of his own. Having fought when he was younger, Rains Fall has lost his wife and elder son to soldiers. He tells Arthur he signed three treaties, each broken. With the Army pressing to remove his people from reservation land coveted for oil, he pursues diplomacy against Leviticus Cornwall’s business interests.
“We cannot fight another war,” he pleads.
His encounters with Arthur also make room for care. In “Archeology for Beginners,” Rains Fall gathers plants to ease Arthur’s cough and listens to him speak about his life. Finding a sacred site destroyed and its ceremonial objects stolen, he asks Arthur to recover them without hurting anyone. Completing that task without killing the soldiers earns Arthur the Owl Feather Trinket.
That encounter asks the player to practise the restraint Rains Fall advocates. His approach carries the memory of violence, broken agreements and the people he is trying to protect.
In the epilogue, John can meet him at Annesburg station. The Wapiti have fled to Canada; Rains Fall has returned to mourn Eagle Flies. Greene gives the story a survivor who continues living with its losses.
Before release, writer Dan Houser called Rains Fall “a gentle soul in that violent world” in Vulture.
Greene brought a career spanning his Oscar-nominated work in Dances with Wolves and his later role on Reservation Dogs. “I’m a working actor,” he told the Television Academy in 2023, speaking about roles ranging from Indigenous characters to judges and New York police officers. He died in 2025.
Eagle Flies and Paytah: The Cost of Dutch’s Promises
Jeremiah Bitsui, who is of Navajo and Omaha descent and is also known as Victor in Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul, performs Eagle Flies.
“Father has confused wisdom with weakness,” Eagle Flies says.
Rains Fall’s surviving son sees the continuing loss of land and freedom as reason to fight. Dutch encourages that anger while hoping a conflict with the Army will divert attention from his own gang. Arthur becomes increasingly troubled by the way Dutch is using him.
During the attack at Cornwall’s oil refinery in “My Last Boy,” Eagle Flies saves Arthur after Dutch abandons him. Colonel Favours mortally wounds Eagle Flies, and Arthur, Charles and Paytah bring him home to his father.
Loren Anthony, a Diné actor, performs Paytah, Eagle Flies’ close companion. Paytah helps recover the Wapiti’s confiscated horses and rides into the conflict at the oil fields. Anthony has publicly shared a reel of his work in the game.
Outside the game, Anthony’s work includes Chizh For Cheii, which provides firewood and mutual aid for elders on the Navajo Nation.
The father–son disagreement and Dutch’s manipulation place the Wapiti’s struggle inside the game’s examination of leadership: who earns trust, who exploits it and who bears the cost.
How Rockstar Built the Story
Rockstar co-founder and writer Dan Houser discussed the Indigenous storyline with Bruno Icher in a 2018 interview published by Le Temps. He said the team imagined a chief drawing on different Tribes, pursuing peace while in conflict with his more impetuous son. He credited Greene with a subtle performance that helped the game avoid familiar Western clichés.
That account establishes a deliberate creative choice and the hiring of an Indigenous performer. The Wapiti are a fictional people; Houser’s description of a composite character does not identify a single living Nation as their model.
The production was built around years of writing and performance work. Houser’s senior writing partners included Michael Unsworth and Rupert Humphries, with performance work recorded at Rockstar’s facility in Bethpage, New York. GQ’s 2018 account described a main story script exceeding 2,000 pages and a main cast working with Rockstar for more than five years. Unsworth later told History Hit that the team reworked dialogue that sounded too much like a stereotypical Western, seeking speech that felt natural to modern players.
The publicly documented engagement includes Greene, Bitsui and Anthony’s performances and Dalal’s account of creating Charles. The sources reviewed for this story do not establish a named formal Tribal consultation partner. That part of the production history remains unconfirmed.
The Question Waiting in Vice City
The reach of these stories is considerable. Take-Two’s 2026 annual report said Red Dead Redemption 2 had shipped more than 80 million copies worldwide.
Rockstar enters the next launch with a record few entertainment companies can match: Guinness World Records recorded Grand Theft Auto V reaching $1 billion in sales in three days in 2013.
GTA VI takes players to Leonida, Rockstar’s fictional Florida. On Nov. 10, IND asked whether the game includes Indigenous actors, characters, creative contributors or themes, including connections to Tequesta, Seminole or Miccosukee peoples. Rockstar replied on Nov. 18, the day before the game’s release, and said it would follow up soon as it prepares for launch.
It is not yet known whether Florida’s Indigenous peoples took part in Grand Theft Auto VI. For a sense of what Indigenous participation and substantial Indigenous characters can bring to a Rockstar world, look back to Red Dead Redemption 2—and to Charles Smith, Rains Fall, Eagle Flies and Paytah.
Share this story
How we reported this
- Grand Theft Auto VI, Rockstar Games
- GTA VI Regional Pre-Load and Release Times, Updated Nov. 3, 2026, Rockstar Games
- Charles Smith, Red Dead Wiki / Fandom
- Rains Fall, Red Dead Wiki / Fandom
- Eagle Flies, Red Dead Wiki / Fandom
- Paytah, Red Dead Wiki / Fandom
- Archeology for Beginners, Red Dead Wiki / Fandom
- The King’s Son, Red Dead Wiki / Fandom
- Bare Knuckle Friendships, Red Dead Wiki / Fandom
- A New Jerusalem, Red Dead Wiki / Fandom
- Red Dead Redemption 2 Lead Cast Members Share Their Inspirations and Favorite Moments, Nov. 8, 2018, GamesRadar+ (Austin Wood)
- Official Website and Performance-Capture Résumé, Noshir Dalal
- Bruno Icher’s Interview With Dan Houser, Oct. 25, 2018, Le Temps (Bruno Icher)
- How the West Was Digitized, Oct. 14, 2018, Vulture (Harold Goldberg)
- Sam White’s Interview With Dan Houser, Oct. 24, 2018, British GQ (Sam White)
- Bringing the Virtual Frontier to Life, July 29, 2021, History Hit (Nick Cowen)
- Graham Greene’s Credit Score, Aug. 16, 2023, Television Academy (Graham Flashner)
- Graham Greene Tribute, Sept. 3, 2025, Six Nations of the Grand River
- Jeremiah Bitsui, Clear Talent Group
- Official Website and Chizh For Cheii, Loren Anthony
- His Red Dead Redemption 2 Reel Announcement, Loren Anthony
- 2026 Annual Report, Form 10-K, Take-Two Interactive
- Fastest Entertainment Property to Gross $1 Billion, Guinness World Records
- Request to Rockstar Games About Indigenous Representation in GTA VI, Nov. 10, 2026, IND



