Land / report

Five Tribal Nations Sue Over Bears Ears and Grand Staircase Monument Cuts

Two new lawsuits challenge Trump’s July proclamations and the dismantling of the Bears Ears Commission.

Rock formations and desert landscape at Grand Staircase-Escalante in Utah.
Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument in Utah, photographed April 11, 2008. Bureau of Land Management (mypubliclands) / CC BY 2.0

Five Tribal Nations have brought two new federal lawsuits challenging President Donald Trump’s cuts to Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments, seeking to protect ancestral homelands and restore the legal framework for their stewardship.

The Native American Rights Fund announced the filings Nov. 18 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. The cases name different groups of plaintiffs:

  • Bears Ears: the Pueblo of Zuni, Ute Mountain Ute Tribe and Hopi Tribe.
  • Grand Staircase-Escalante: the Kaibab Band of Paiute Indians, Paiute Indian Tribe of Utah and Ute Mountain Ute Tribe.

Ute Mountain Ute is a plaintiff in both cases. Together, the complaints represent five distinct Nations.

These are sacred lands, not potential mining sites

Laurel Yellowhorse

The Bears Ears case is numbered 26-cv-4092; the Grand Staircase case is 26-cv-4094. They challenge the 2026 proclamations, adding a new round of litigation to the long-running dispute over presidential authority to reduce national monuments.

A Dispute Over Homelands and Stewardship

The Nations describe the landscapes as places where their citizens pray, gather medicines, visit ancestors and teach younger generations. Their argument concerns both protection of those places and their governments’ role in caring for them.

“These lands are an unbroken record of who we are and where we come from,” Zuni Head Councilman Anthony Sanchez said in NARF’s announcement.

Paiute Indian Tribe of Utah Chairwoman Laurel Yellowhorse said of Grand Staircase: “These are sacred lands, not potential mining sites.”

At Bears Ears, the challenge reaches beyond acreage. Trump’s proclamation disbands the Bears Ears Commission, the body through which representatives of five Tribal Nations helped guide monument management, and removes the agencies’ obligation to work with it under the earlier proclamations.

The Bears Ears plaintiffs also allege that federal agencies have stopped following the resource management plan’s requirements for Tribal collaboration. They cite failures to notify or work with the Commission on projects, including post-wildfire work, and ask the court to require compliance.

The twin Bears Ears buttes rise above a wooded landscape in Utah.
The Bears Ears buttes in Utah, photographed Aug. 13, 2016. Bob Wick / Bureau of Land Management

What Trump Changed

The July 13 proclamations reduce Bears Ears from about 1.36 million acres to roughly 121,100 acres, and Grand Staircase-Escalante from about 1.87 million acres to approximately 181,500 acres, according to the White House.

Trump argues that the Antiquities Act requires monuments to cover only the smallest area compatible with protecting specified historic or scientific objects. His administration says the larger designations included land and features that did not require monument protection, and that other federal laws continue to protect cultural and archaeological resources.

The proclamations also provide for lands removed from the monuments to become available under public-land, mineral-leasing and mining laws, subject to other applicable restrictions. At Bears Ears, the administration says consultation required by other legal authorities will continue despite terminating the Commission.

The Nations contest both the president’s authority and the resulting loss of protections. They argue that Congress authorized presidents to create monuments under the Antiquities Act, while retaining the power to revoke them.

What the Court Is Being Asked to Do

Both complaints seek declarations that the 2026 proclamations are unlawful and that the protections restored by President Joe Biden in 2021 remain controlling. They also seek orders preventing agencies from implementing the reductions and from treating mining claims based on those reductions as valid.

The Grand Staircase plaintiffs additionally ask the court to confirm that the existing resource management plan remains binding unless lawfully amended. The Bears Ears plaintiffs seek restoration of the Commission’s role and enforcement of the plan’s collaboration requirements.

Those are requests for judicial relief. Filing a lawsuit does not itself provide an injunction or resolve the dispute over presidential power.

The new cases follow Trump’s first reductions in 2017 and Biden’s restoration of the monuments in 2021. The Bears Ears complaint says challenges to the 2017 action are still pending; this filing addresses the new proclamation and agencies’ actions under it.

Share this story

How we reported this

Relevant stories

Browse stories →