Politics / brief

Senate Advances Permitting Bill 73–25 After NCAI Urged a No Vote

The procedural vote moves the Senate toward debate on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. NCAI says the manager's amendment still threatens Tribal sovereignty and sacred places.

The United States Capitol in Washington, D.C.
The U.S. Capitol in Washington, D.C. Architect of the Capitol

The U.S. Senate voted 73–25 on Nov. 9 to advance permitting legislation that the National Congress of American Indians had urged senators to oppose, Source NM and New Mexico Political Report reported.

The vote invoked cloture on the motion to proceed to H.R. 2347, the legislative vehicle for the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, S. 5653. It needed 60 votes. It moves the Senate toward considering the bill; it is not a vote to pass it. Senators can still offer amendments, a final Senate vote is expected in the coming days, and the House would then have to take up the bill.

On Nov. 8, NCAI called for the withdrawal of Division B, Title III of the bill and for Congress to work directly with Tribal Nations as sovereigns. It said the new manager's amendment leaves its concerns about Tribal sovereignty and sacred places unresolved.

NCAI acknowledged that the substitute removes a proposed mandate for the Interior Department to take over Tribal Historic Preservation Offices. The organization nevertheless argues that other provisions would still allow agencies to bypass Tribal participation and weaken historic-preservation review.

Members of the All Pueblo Council of Governors traveled to Washington to urge a no vote, Source NM reported.

NDN Collective had called for the bill to be withdrawn in an Oct. 23 statement. President Wizipan Garriot and senior domestic policy strategist Davis Price criticized the original proposal's effects on consultation and Tribal sovereignty. Their statement predates the new substitute.

NCAI's position follows earlier objections from Tribal organizations, including the Native American Rights Fund, to changes in the National Historic Preservation Act's Section 106 review process.

Share this story

How we reported this

Relevant stories

Browse stories →