Politics / report

Northern Arapaho Leaves COLT Over BAAJA: ‘We Will Speak for Ourselves’

The Tribe’s withdrawal exposes a disagreement over permitting reform; COLT says seeking amendments did not mean endorsing the bill.

Sagebrush plain beneath snow-covered mountains and a pale moon on the Wind River Reservation in Wyoming.
The Wind River Reservation in Wyoming, shared by the Northern Arapaho and Eastern Shoshone Tribes, photographed April 13, 2017. Angela Burgess / USFWS

The Northern Arapaho Tribe has withdrawn from the Coalition of Large Tribes amid a dispute over the coalition’s approach to the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, the federal permitting package known as BAAJA.

A Nov. 16 notice carried on the Tribe’s official website says the withdrawal takes effect immediately. “We will speak for ourselves,” the notice says.

“We no longer align ourselves with an organization that acts against the interests of its member Tribes,” Northern Arapaho Business Council Chairman Keenan Groesbeck said in the withdrawal release, as reported by Wyoming Public Media.

Our history does not stop at the reservation boundary

Keenan Groesbeck

COLT’s executive director had published a different account of the coalition’s role five days earlier. O.J. Semans Sr., who is Rosebud Sioux, said COLT sought changes to a bill it considered harmful, that most member Tribes opposed it, and that the coalition had no unanimous position supporting passage.

The Northern Arapaho Position

The Tribe’s opposition predates its departure. In a Nov. 10 statement, Groesbeck urged Congress to remove historic-preservation provisions that weaken existing protections, provide affected Tribal governments the operative text, and allow time for direct government-to-government consultation.

“Our history does not stop at the reservation boundary,” he said.

The statement explains that the Tribe’s ancestral and cultural connections extend beyond the Wind River Reservation, which it shares with the Eastern Shoshone Tribe, into Wyoming, Colorado and the surrounding region. Federal decisions outside reservation boundaries can therefore affect places important to Northern Arapaho people.

The dispute centers on Division B, Title III and its changes to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act. Section 106 requires federal agencies to consider effects on historic properties before making decisions on covered projects. Tribal opponents say the proposed changes would narrow review and weaken their ability to protect ancestral places.

What COLT Says It Did

In his Nov. 11 explanation, published on COLT’s website, Semans said removing Title III was the coalition’s preferred approach. When congressional offices said the title would remain, he said, COLT proposed changes intended to reduce its harm.

He credited that work with revisions involving Tribal historic-preservation programs, consultation deadlines and confidentiality. He also acknowledged continuing problems with federal agency discretion, the scope of review and court remedies.

“They do not mean COLT supports the bill,” Semans wrote of the amendments. He said individual Tribes retained their own positions and that COLT needed unanimity to adopt a position on passage. His explanation preceded Northern Arapaho’s withdrawal; it was not a response issued afterward.

The Coalition’s Membership

COLT was established in 2011 to advocate for Tribes governing large land bases. Its membership directory identifies Northern Arapaho as a founding member and currently lists these member governments:

  • Spokane Tribe of Indians
  • Shoshone-Bannock Tribes
  • Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe
  • Navajo Nation
  • Rosebud Sioux Tribe
  • Sisseton-Wahpeton Oyate
  • Ute Indian Tribe
  • Blackfeet Nation
  • Eastern Shoshone Tribe
  • Fort Belknap Indian Community
  • Mandan, Hidatsa and Arikara Nation
  • San Carlos Apache Tribe

Membership does not establish a Nation’s position on BAAJA. COLT’s homepage also names the Crow Tribe and Spirit Lake Tribe; its public pages do not present an identical roster.

Support and Opposition Beyond COLT

The Crow Tribe urged Congress to advance BAAJA, City Journal reported, citing its support letter. In the same report, National Tribal Energy Association Chairman Daniel Cardenas, who is a member of the Pit River Tribe, argued that clearer permitting could attract investment in energy, housing, water and other infrastructure on Tribal lands.

“But having those choices, that’s sovereignty,” Cardenas said in his interview with City Journal.

On the other side, 11 national and regional Tribal organizations issued a Nov. 8 statement saying amendments had not resolved their objections. They asked Congress to delay the legislation for consultation or, at minimum, remove Title III. Signatories include the National Congress of American Indians, Native American Rights Fund and National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers.

The differences concern both development on Tribal lands and protection of ancestral places elsewhere. No organization’s position or membership speaks for every Tribal Nation.

The Bill and the Senate Vote

BAAJA was introduced as S. 5653 and is moving in the Senate through substitute amendment 6883 to H.R. 2347. The Senate adopted that substitute 69–27 on Nov. 18 and then voted 65–31 to limit further debate on the amended bill. Those votes were not final passage.

The substitute narrows the projects covered by historic-preservation review, sets consultation deadlines and generally limits remedies for preservation-law violations to sending decisions back to agencies for correction without setting them aside. Its preliminary-injunction exception requires, among other conditions, a likely violation of a different federal law, excluding the preservation law and the National Environmental Policy Act.

The text also says the Interior secretary is not authorized to consult on a Tribe’s behalf and that federal agencies remain obliged to consult. Northern Arapaho has asked for protections and direct consultation that preserve its authority to speak for its people and ancestral places.

The Senate passed the amended bill 62–33 late Thursday, Nov. 19, sending it to the House.

Share this story

How we reported this

Relevant stories

Browse stories →