Politics / report

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act Passes the Senate

The federal permitting package moves to the House amid competing Native perspectives on sacred places, consultation and development on Tribal lands.

The illuminated U.S. Capitol dome and an American flag against a dark blue evening sky.
The U.S. Capitol in Washington, D.C. Orhan Cam / Shutterstock.com

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, known as BAAJA, is a sweeping permitting bill intended to speed federal approval of energy and other infrastructure projects. The Senate passed it 62–33 on Nov. 19, sending the package to the House of Representatives.

The legislation would change environmental-review and permitting rules under laws including the National Environmental Policy Act, Clean Water Act, Endangered Species Act and National Historic Preservation Act. Its sponsors say faster approvals would help build transmission lines, power projects and other infrastructure while lowering electricity costs. The package covers both renewable-energy and fossil-fuel development.

What’s at Stake for Indigenous Peoples

For Tribal Nations, the controversy concerns who can influence decisions before a project damages land, water or places of religious and cultural importance, and what remedies remain if federal agencies fail to follow the law.

Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act currently requires federal agencies to consider effects on historic properties before proceeding with covered projects. The process includes consultation and public participation. Native opponents say BAAJA’s changes would narrow those opportunities and weaken protection of ancestral places.

The National Congress of American Indians and other Native organizations argue that these safeguards reflect federal obligations to sovereign Nations. Their objection is that a faster review cannot repair the loss of a sacred place once it has been destroyed.

NDN Collective called the Senate vote a “rubber stamp on the Administration’s agenda” and urged the House to reject the bill.

Wizipan Garriott, the organization’s Sicangu Lakota president, argued that BAAJA would accelerate data centers and the mining, water use and land development that support them at the expense of Tribal sovereignty.

He said permitting reform should instead be developed with Tribal leaders and the communities most affected. NDN Collective says it has been mobilizing Indigenous people and allies with partners including Climate Justice Alliance, and is asking people to contact their representatives.

How the Bill Passed

The package was developed by Republican Sens. Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia and Mike Lee of Utah, alongside Democrats Martin Heinrich of New Mexico and Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island.

Originally introduced as S. 5653, BAAJA advanced through substitute amendment 6883 to H.R. 2347. Senators adopted the substitute 69–27 on Nov. 18, then voted 65–31 to end debate on the amended bill. Final passage followed Nov. 19.

The yes votes came from 47 Republicans, 14 Democrats and independent Angus King of Maine. Republican Sens. Josh Hawley of Missouri and Mike Rounds of South Dakota voted no. Five senators did not vote.

The Democrats voting yes were Chris Coons, John Fetterman, Ruben Gallego, Martin Heinrich, John Hickenlooper, Amy Klobuchar, Gary Peters, Jack Reed, Jacky Rosen, Brian Schatz, Chuck Schumer, Elissa Slotkin, Mark Warner and Sheldon Whitehouse.

Heinrich described the deal after passage as a “hard-fought bipartisan agreement.” He said it would bring more affordable energy onto the grid, make data centers pay a larger share of electricity and grid costs, and strengthen Tribal consultation. Those claimed benefits are central to the sponsors’ case and remain contested by Native opponents.

Reactions Across Indian Country

NCAI and its Native organization partners had rejected the latest manager’s amendment before the vote. Their Nov. 17 statement called for the bill to be stopped altogether and for a recorded vote on Sen. Adam Schiff’s proposal to remove its historic-preservation title.

“Our position has not changed. Congress must reject BAAJA in its entirety,” the organizations wrote.

John Washines, a Yakama Nation Tribal Council member and chair of its Fish and Wildlife Committee, connected the issue to the effects of energy development on salmon in the Columbia and Snake river basin. He spoke at a pre-vote news conference reported by The Spokesman-Review.

“We know the danger of treating environmental harm as something to fix later,” Washines said.

Cindy Marchand, chairwoman of the Confederated Tribes of the Colville Reservation, also opposed the package. In a letter reported by the newspaper, she argued that the Tribes’ ancestral territory extends beyond the reservation, making consultation over projects elsewhere essential to protecting cultural resources.

Marchand said the revised historic-preservation title remained “unworkable for Indian country.” Both leaders supported permitting reform while opposing this approach.

Other Native advocates see clearer approvals as an opportunity to exercise sovereignty over development on Tribal lands. National Tribal Energy Association Chairman Daniel Cardenas, a member of the Pit River Tribe, told City Journal that permitting uncertainty makes projects harder to finance.

Our position has not changed. Congress must reject BAAJA in its entirety

National Congress of American Indians and partner organizations, Nov. 17

“We want jobs too, right?” Cardenas said. The outlet reported support letters from the association and the Crow Tribe, with Cardenas arguing that clearer rules could attract investment in energy, water, broadband and housing.

The Coalition of Large Tribes’ position is more qualified. In a Nov. 11 statement on the coalition’s website, executive director O.J. Semans Sr., who is Rosebud Sioux, said removing the historic-preservation title had been COLT’s first preference. When congressional offices said the title would remain, COLT sought amendments intended to reduce harm.

Semans said members disagreed on passage, so the coalition had no collective endorsement of the bill. The Northern Arapaho Tribe subsequently withdrew from COLT amid disagreement over its approach, as IND reported.

What Senate Passage Now Means

The Senate vote advances the package but does not enact it. The House must agree to the Senate’s version before it can go to the president. If representatives change the Senate text, the chambers must resolve those differences.

For Native opponents, that leaves another opportunity to seek rejection or changes. For supporters of faster permitting, the House is the next test of a package they argue would expand development and investment.

The disagreement reaches across two related questions: how Nations can pursue projects on their own lands, and how they can protect ancestral places affected by decisions beyond reservation boundaries.

When the House Could Vote

House consideration is expected after the Thanksgiving break, with lawmakers due to return Nov. 30. A specific BAAJA vote date had not been confirmed as of Nov. 20.

NDN Collective is pressing representatives to use that next stage to stop the package and involve affected communities in a different approach to permitting reform.

“But the fight is not over,” its release says.

Share this story

How we reported this

Relevant stories

Browse stories →